Wooden domino-like blocks
Wooden domino-like blocks

Commoditized Captives & Why “Elegance Without Warmth Is Arrogance”

Category /
Program Strategy

Share

Subscribe

One of the most insightful business quotes is from Horst Schulze, former CEO of Ritz-Carlton, “Elegance without warmth is arrogance.”

Let’s unpack that for a minute.

During an interview with Knowledge@Wharton radio show, Schulze further explained that real excellence for the customer was individualization, rather than commoditization. And the reason why so many companies end up commoditizing, is their myopic focus on the bottom line. They became too big to navigate the nuances of their customers and made comprises on their product or service. As Schulze put it:

“Rather than make the soap a little smaller so you make more profit, eliminate your own mistakes. Work on your own processes and continue improvement and eliminate costs, consequently. Every time I eliminate a mistake permanently, I save money and improve my product at the same time.”

Let’s apply this line of thinking to the captive industry.

Perhaps this explains why some captive program managers rely on rate caps rather than proactive claims management? It should be no surprise then why rate caps are used most by the largest captive managers.

They have lost the ability (even willingness) to improve their product.

They will accept any employer and one size fits all because they’ve commoditized their captive structure.

You could even say there’s an arrogance to how they do business with their broker “partners.”

Here at Everlong, we believe in innovation and continuously improving our product over time. That’s why from the very beginning, with our first cell in 2010, we took the current captive model used in the business liability world, modified its structure, and improved its performance.

This approach continues more than a decade later and why we will never compromise our captive structure. Our commitment to excellence is another reason why there are no more than 50 members per cell within our high performance health insurance captives.

We don’t commoditize, we optimize.

Learn more about Everlong’s captive health insurance solutions.

Join the inner circle. Know the difference.

Get access to the latest from Everlong and issues shaping group health.

Related Articles

Read more from Everlong’s team of experts.

Man in corporate clothes smiling

Why Ownership Matters: Unpacking the Benefits of a Health Insurance Captive

In the fast-evolving landscape of healthcare and employee benefits, employers often find themselves navigating a labyrinth of choices and compromises. Health insurance serves as both a fundamental necessity for employee well-being and a persistent source of financial and administrative burden for employers.

Read the Article
Different yellow 3d shapes

The Strategic Value of Specialized Protection

Let's talk about something most programs gloss over: the power of choice in risk management. Not because it's complicated, but because giving employers real control over their protection strategy doesn't fit their one-size-fits-all model. Here's the reality: Every employer faces unique risks, and they deserve the ability to address those risks on their own terms.

Read the Article
Man wondering how to climb a wall

Moving From Spectator to Decision Maker

For too long, employers have been relegated to the sidelines of their own healthcare story. They write the checks, bear the risk, and face the consequences – but when it comes to actual decisions? They're often treated like spectators in their own game. It's time for that to change.

Read the Article
Colorful ropes tied together

Building Long-Term Program Stability

Everyone talks about stability like it's some mystical force that appears once you reach a certain size or age. But real stability – the kind that delivers negative trend lines and consistent surpluses – isn't about size. It's about making the right decisions, consistently, even when they're hard.

Read the Article

© 2012-

Designed by